Hydrogen mitigation in submerged arc welding

Abstract

With the role of hydrogen in weld metal well understood in its relation to cold cracking, there has been a push to produce welds with lower and lower diffusible hydrogen contents. The push for lower diffusible hydrogen contents has placed pressure on consumables manufactures to create consumables that can achieve the requirements for lower diffusible hydrogen content. Currently EM12K flux is produced so that it can achieve below 4 ml of diffusible hydrogen for every 100g of weld metal deposited (ml/100g) for submerged arc welding (SAW). The recent trend for industry is to preferentially achieve diffusible hydrogen contents below 3 ml/100g. Making it necessary to find a way to modify the flux to achieve a lower diffusible hydrogen content for the welds it produces. To achieve this goal a two phase plan was developed. The first phase was to characterize the entire welding system for hydrogen. Since the goal of the project is hydrogen mitigation, any amount of hydrogen that could be reduced is helpful and therefore must first be discovered. Sources of hydrogen may be found by analyzing the welding wire and base metal, as well as breaking the flux down into its components and production steps. The wire was analyzed for total hydrogen content as was the base metal. The flux and its components were analyzed using differential thermal analysis-simultaneous thermal analysis (DTA-STA) and later vacuum degassing for moisture content. The analysis of the wire showed that the copper coating on the wire was the largest contributor of hydrogen. There was lubricant present on the wire surface as well, but it did not contribute as much as the copper coating. It was found that a simple low temperature baking of the wire was enough to remove the lubricant and coating moisture. The base metal was found to have a similar total hydrogen content to that of the wire. The breakdown of the flux and production process for moisture content analysis revealed that the production process removes the moisture that is added by the water based binder. The second phase of the project was to modify the flux with fluoride additions to remove hydrogen from the arc while welding. The introduction of fluorine into the arc would lower the amount of hydrogen that may be absorbed as diffusible hydrogen by the weld metal. To select the fluorides a series of thermodynamic calculations were performed as well as simple tests to determine the fluorides behavior in a welding arc and flux. From these tests the following fluorides were selected to be used to be added to EM12K flux as oneweight percent additions: SrF2, K2TiF6, K2SiF6, and LiF. Welds were then run with the experimental fluxes according to AWS A4.3 standard for diffusible hydrogen testing. From these tests it was found that none experimental fluxes were able to achieve a diffusible hydrogen content lower than the original EM12K flux. It was also found that fluoride reduction in a simple flux is a better predictor of fluoride effectiveness than decomposition temperature.